Why Competitive Intelligence Needs its Own Wargame Now

Cameron Turner Cameron Turner
February 15, 2019 AI & Machine Learning

Try introducing yourself as a Competitive Intelligence analyst. Chances are that the reactions will range from

a) That’s what you do all day, Google search?

to

(b) Identifying 007 ways to look at competition, Corporate Bond?

Of course, one can always resort to the classical definition of Competitive Intelligence (CI). It is defined as the action of defining, gathering, analyzing,and distributing intelligence about products, customers, competitors, and any aspect of the environment needed to support executives and managers making strategic decisions for an organization.

Given today’s dynamic business environment and the rise of disruptive innovators that are challenging traditional business models across industries, this should be the golden age of CI, right? But a look at Google Trends shows this:

experfy-blog

What’s gone wrong? Remember that old joke a man was too busy driving to stop for gas? Is that what’s ailing CI? Failing to recognize the disruptive innovations that is changing its own game? As the CI ninjas faithfully use the well-known and unchanged frameworks and send out, with unfailing frequency, the key deliverables such as:

  • Newsletter
  • Competitor Profiles
  • Battlecards
  • Wargaming and scenario planning
  • Intelligence briefings

do they hear questions like I already knew this, Where’s the insight?, I need something real-time, How can I measure success from my CI investment?, What strategic action can I take now? from the key CI consumers in the business? (Consumers including Strategy, Marketing, Product, Research, Sales teams).

Maybe there’s help. From one of its own techniques. Let’s hone in on the wargaming technique. Defined as a role-played simulation of a business situation, it involves a set of teams representing a market or customer, a set of competitors, and a series of other uncontrollable factors or entities. If we apply it on CI today, what does the world look like for CI?

1) Customer: Assume, you are part of the Strategy Planning team ofBlackRock Investments, an investment management group analyzing its competitorexperfy-blog. When Fortune published its 2013 list of the world’s 50 Most Admired Companies, five among them were 25 years old or less. Four were the usual suspects from the tech land: Amazon, eBay, Facebook, Google. And there was BlackRock, formed in 1988, a Financial Services company. $4.3T in assets. But the CEO has still set a target for 5% organic growth y-o-y. Is that achievable? That’s the question. Can a clear understanding of who and why we are doing CI help in the first step of defining CI better per the classical definition? Our customer here is the Strategy team, not Marketing, not Sales, not Product. That’s critical for the CI analyst to know.

2) Set of competitors: Assume your usual deliverable is a detailed competitor profile on BlackRock. Is that enough? What could change the competition for your BlackRock profile and provide the real insight the customer asked for?

a) Automation and real-time monitoring in CI: Annual report, investor presentations, earnings transcripts, SEC filings, fund performance data from SimFund, eVestment, Morningstar, analyst views, industry news from Financial Times, Investment News, Pension and Investments. Phew. An ocean of data the CI analyst needs to wade through to even start attacking the problem.

Luckily there is help. Tools such as Feedly can help automate the newsfeeds and personalize the news the CI analyst can read to remove all the additional noise that can result in data drip (data rich, insight poor).

And then there are tools such as ClearCI which use all the CI sources and provide automated monitoring dashboards for CI.

experfy-blog

Could such tools help in step 2 of the CI definition: information gathering?

b) Digital analysis in CI: Digital data has unleashed a new surge of tools that claim to track all digital competitive data from social mentions, text analysis of online product feedback to understanding keywords that drive traffic.

Imagine adding these to step 3 of CI, the analysis stage in the traditional CI definition. You could check what customers are saying about BlackRock, which funds are they advertising more and which ones are bringing in more traffic. Can this enriched analysis make CI more predictive?

c) Visualization in CI: Once a data-provider like Bloomberg, which is also a competitor for CI today, providing powerful, interactive visualization of the key industry and competitor statistics that earlier used to consume hours of excel and powerpoint time. On a single scroll, you can look at the marketshare, the historical financial performance of BlackRock vs. competitors.

Spooked? But why wait for Bloomberg, anyone with a visualization like Tableau can use this technique for the final step, easier distribution of CI as per the classical definition.

Of course there are other uncontrollable factors, as always, in a wargame. But by holistically looking at the customer and the competition for itself, can CI make itself more relevant in today’s world?

Let’s go back to the question that we were trying to answer on BlackRock’s growth target. Equity fund performance, management changes, retail build out of BlackRock are few of the themes that the CI analyst would hopefully get through the wargaming exercise and the plethora of tools. These themes could then be analyzed in more detail to assess the key drivers and the impact contributors and then monitor only those, real-time, interactively, to understand the real game.

Can all this make CI more relevant? The tools will help for sure. But the real reason why the interest in CI seems to be declining is not just the emergence of new tools and techniques. It is the lack of real predictive insight from CI that companies can use to drive strategy and and stop freezing Kodak moments forever. Vincent Barabba’s classical book on Kodak’s failure named The Decision Loom brought home this point powerfully. Wargame or no wargame, can CI analysts bring back the strategy in CI?

Would love to hear your comments and thoughts.

Note: The tools mentioned in this post are just indicative, they are not meant to be an exhaustive list.

  • Experfy Insights

    Top articles, research, podcasts, webinars and more delivered to you monthly.

  • Cameron Turner

    Tags
    Customer and Marketing Analytics
    © 2021, Experfy Inc. All rights reserved.
    Leave a Comment
    Next Post
    What’s Your Digital Transformation Story?

    What's Your Digital Transformation Story?

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    More in AI & Machine Learning
    AI & Machine Learning,Future of Work
    AI’s Role in the Future of Work

    Artificial intelligence is shaping the future of work around the world in virtually every field. The role AI will play in employment in the years ahead is dynamic and collaborative. Rather than eliminating jobs altogether, AI will augment the capabilities and resources of employees and businesses, allowing them to do more with less. In more

    5 MINUTES READ Continue Reading »
    AI & Machine Learning
    How Can AI Help Improve Legal Services Delivery?

    Everybody is discussing Artificial Intelligence (AI) and machine learning, and some legal professionals are already leveraging these technological capabilities.  AI is not the future expectation; it is the present reality.  Aside from law, AI is widely used in various fields such as transportation and manufacturing, education, employment, defense, health care, business intelligence, robotics, and so

    5 MINUTES READ Continue Reading »
    AI & Machine Learning
    5 AI Applications Changing the Energy Industry

    The energy industry faces some significant challenges, but AI applications could help. Increasing demand, population expansion, and climate change necessitate creative solutions that could fundamentally alter how businesses generate and utilize electricity. Industry researchers looking for ways to solve these problems have turned to data and new data-processing technology. Artificial intelligence, in particular — and

    3 MINUTES READ Continue Reading »

    About Us

    Incubated in Harvard Innovation Lab, Experfy specializes in pipelining and deploying the world's best AI and engineering talent at breakneck speed, with exceptional focus on quality and compliance. Enterprises and governments also leverage our award-winning SaaS platform to build their own customized future of work solutions such as talent clouds.

    Join Us At

    Contact Us

    1700 West Park Drive, Suite 190
    Westborough, MA 01581

    Email: support@experfy.com

    Toll Free: (844) EXPERFY or
    (844) 397-3739

    © 2025, Experfy Inc. All rights reserved.